Recipe for: Grilled King Oyster Mushrooms with Herb Butter and Lemon Dip - photo 1
← Recipes

Recipe for: Grilled King Oyster Mushrooms with Herb Butter and Lemon Dip

Spicy Snacks Grilling 15 min Easy 27 views ~9.88 PLN * - (0)
Rate:
(0)
Start Cooking

Description

Delicate oyster mushrooms marinated in herby-garlic butter, quickly grilled to a golden-brown, slightly crispy edge and served with a refreshing yogurt and lemon-based dip. The dish combines the rustic character of Polish mushrooms with a modern, summery twist: smoked paprika and parsley enhance the flavor, while optional honey and sesame add contrasting sweetness and texture. Perfect as a light snack for a picnic, garden party, or as a side to grilled meat. Visually appetizing: the golden edges of the mushrooms, green accents of parsley, the white of the creamy dip, and possible golden drops of honey.

Ingredients Used

Ingredients (13)

Servings:
4
  • Oyster mushroom 600 g
  • Butter 50 g
  • Rapeseed oil 30 g
  • Garlic 2 clove (~10 g)
  • Natural yogurt 150 g
  • Lemon 0.6 pcs (~50 g)
  • 🌿 Spices
  • Salt 2 g
  • Black pepper 4 pinch (~2 g)
  • Smoked paprika 2 tsp (~4 g)
  • Thyme 2 g
  • Parsley 0.5 bunch (~15 g)
  • ✨ Optional
  • Honey 20 ml
  • Sesame 10 g
💰 Estimated dish cost: ~9.88 PLN (2.47 PLN/serving)
* Prices missing for some ingredients

💡 Click an ingredient to mark it as used

Preparation steps

Preparing oyster mushrooms

1

Clean the oyster mushrooms: remove the tough ends of the stems with a knife (only trim the dry, woody part). If the caps are very large, tear them by hand along the layers to create wide strips about 1–2 cm thick — this will ensure even grilling. You can leave larger pieces uncut, as they will look impressive on the plate.

Ingredients: oyster mushroom
Use a sharp knife and a large cutting board. Do not wash the oyster mushrooms under running water for a long time — wipe them with a damp cloth or quickly rinse and dry with a paper towel to prevent them from soaking up water.

Marinade

2

In a small saucepan over very low heat, melt the butter (about 1 minute) and add the rapeseed oil — this combination will lower the smoke point. Add finely chopped or crushed garlic (10 g), smoked paprika (4 g), thyme (2 g), salt (1 g of the 2 g planned), and half of the chopped parsley (about 7 g) to the mixture. Heat for 30–45 seconds until the aromas combine; do not allow the garlic to brown. Remove from heat and set aside.

Ingredients: Butter, Rapeseed oil, Garlic, Smoked paprika, Thyme, Parsley, Salt
Use a small saucepan or a metal bowl over a low flame. Do not heat the butter too much — it should only melt and release its aroma. If you don't have a saucepan, you can use a ceramic bowl and melt the butter in a water bath.
3

Place the prepared oyster mushrooms in a large bowl. Drizzle with warm (not hot) marinade and gently mix with two tongs or your hand in a disposable glove, ensuring all surfaces are coated. Let sit for 5 minutes — the marinade will slightly penetrate the mushrooms, but do not let them sit longer than 15 minutes, as they will absorb too much fat.

Ingredients: oyster mushroom, Butter, Rapeseed oil, Garlic, Smoked paprika, Thyme, Salt, Parsley
Use a large, wide bowl to be able to toss the oyster mushrooms without breaking them. If you don't have tongs, use two large kitchen spoons.

Dip

4

Prepare the dip: in a medium bowl, combine natural yogurt (150 g) with the juice and grated zest of half a lemon (about 50 g of lemon including juice: squeeze out ~1 tablespoon of juice). Add crushed garlic (5 g) or finely chopped garlic, the remaining chopped parsley (about 8 g), a pinch of salt, and freshly ground pepper. Mix with a spoon for 20–30 seconds until smooth. Taste and adjust seasoning with lemon juice or salt if needed.

Ingredients: Natural yogurt, Lemon, Garlic, Parsley, Salt, Black pepper, Honey
Use a fine grater to zest the lemon (only the yellow part). If the dip is too sour, you can add a teaspoon of honey (optional). Use a metal or silicone spoon for mixing.

Grilling

5

Preheat the grill to medium-high heat (about 200–220°C). If using a charcoal grill, wait until the coals are covered with light ash; if using a gas grill, heat for 8–10 minutes. Brush the grates with oil using a brush or a paper towel on tongs to prevent sticking.

Ingredients: Rapeseed oil
Use a silicone brush or a piece of paper towel soaked in oil and tongs. The grill must be hot — a light smoke and sizzle when placing the mushroom is a good sign.
6

Place the oyster mushrooms on a hot grill in a single layer (use a grilling basket or foil with holes if the pieces are small). Grill for 2–3 minutes without moving them, until the bottom is browned and dark stripes appear. Turn with tongs and grill for another 2–3 minutes. During the second grilling, brush the mushrooms with the remaining marinade or spoon it over them to achieve a glossy surface and intense flavor. The oyster mushrooms are ready when the edges are golden and slightly crispy, and the inside is soft and juicy.

Ingredients: oyster mushroom, Butter, Rapeseed oil, Garlic, Smoked paprika, Thyme, Salt, Parsley
Use tongs to turn and a silicone brush to baste. If the pieces are thick, lower the temperature and extend the time by 1–2 minutes per side. Do not burn the garlic — if you see the garlic darkening in the marinade, reduce the heat.

Resting and Finishing

7

After removing from the grill, set the oyster mushrooms on a plate for 2 minutes to let the juices stabilize slightly. Sprinkle fresh parsley on top and season with freshly ground pepper. If you are using sesame seeds (optional), quickly sprinkle them on the hot mushrooms — they will gently stick to the oily surface. You can also lightly drizzle a bit of honey (optional) for a contrast of flavors.

Ingredients: Parsley, Black pepper, Sesame, Honey
Use a board or a wide plate for resting. Do not cover the mushrooms with foil — they will steam underneath and become soft instead of being slightly crispy.

Serving

8

Arrange the oyster mushrooms on a large platter or plates, and place a bowl of lemon dip next to them. Serve immediately while the mushrooms are still warm. The dish pairs wonderfully with dark bread, a light cucumber and dill salad, or as an appetizer to grilled meat.

Ingredients: oyster mushroom, Natural yogurt, Lemon
Use a wide platter and a nice bowl for the dip. Serve with napkins and small forks – the oyster mushrooms can be slightly greasy.

Fun Fact

💡

Oyster mushrooms are easy to cultivate; in Poland, they have gained popularity in home and restaurant cooking due to their meaty texture, which perfectly mimics the texture of grilled meat.

Best for

Majówka Impreza w ogrodzie Przekąska przy grillu

Tips

🍽️ Serving

Serve the oyster mushrooms immediately after removing them from the grill with a bowl of cool dip. A slice of well-baked bread or a light salad of young leaves will complement the dish. For a vegan version, replace the butter with oil and the yogurt with plant-based yogurt.

🥡 Storage

Store in the refrigerator in a closed container for up to 24 hours. To reheat, warm on a skillet or grill for 2–3 minutes to restore crispness. Do not freeze after grilling — the texture will deteriorate.

📸 Cooked by the community

Log in to add a photo
Add a photo of the finished dish

After moderator approval, you will receive 10 experience points.

🍲

No one has added a photo yet. Be the first!

Comments (0)

Be the first to comment on this recipe!

Add a comment

You might also like

Cottage cheese with radish and chives 10 min

Cottage cheese with radish and chives

Vegetarian Dishes
Cheese and Spinach Tortilla 15 min

Cheese and Spinach Tortilla

Snacks
Smoked mackerel with bread, cottage cheese, and sorrel 10 min

Smoked mackerel with bread, cottage cheese...

Snacks
Avocado Pasta on Bread with Radish and Chives 10 min

Avocado Pasta on Bread with Radish and Chives

Vegetarian Dishes
Skewers with mushrooms and green asparagus with sorrel dip 25 min

Skewers with mushrooms and green asparagus...

Snacks
Casserole with cheese and mushrooms 20 min

Casserole with cheese and mushrooms

Snacks

Recipe Categories

Snacks
Snacks in: New Year's Eve

Snacks are the perfect way to make the wait for midnight more enjoyable; they should be small but impressive.

See all recipes in this category
Grilling
Grilling

Grilling is the art of preparing dishes over an open flame - the taste of summer and outdoor gatherings. Recipes for grilled meats: beef steak, pork neck, BBQ ribs, and chicken wings. Marinades that tenderize meat and add flavor: herb, Asian, honey-mustard. Grilled vegetables: bell peppers, zucch...

See all recipes in this category
Advertisement